Origins 6(2):59 (1979).
PLEASE NOTE: Unfortunately, we are unable to reproduce all of the special accent marks that were present in our printed version of the Hebrew transliteration. Our apologies for any inconvenience this might cause.
Re: Anderson: Reactions (ORIGINS 6:7)
Professor Anderson's query illustrates the usefulness of consulting
the original language of the biblical text, for a direct reading of Genesis 2 in the
English translation he has quoted could indeed convey the impression that animals were
created after man. The Hebrew verbal system differs from that of English by having only
two tenses, the imperfect and the perfect, and the word "tense" in the temporal
sense does not fit them very well. The imperfect verb yiser in Genesis 2:19 is
preceded by the conjunctional letter waw which in Hebrew has the standard
grammatical effect of converting it into a perfect. In the simplest cases Hebrew perfects
are translated with the English past tense; so this verb commonly has been translated
"formed." The spectrum of English translations for perfect verbs in Hebrew is
broader than just the simple past, however, and in this verse an English past perfect fits
the context best.
One reason for preferring a past perfect translation here is the parenthetical nature of this verse. The preceding verse quotes God as stating that He would make ('e'esÍ) a helper (singular) for Adam. This intent was fulfilled in verse 22 which states that God built (yiben) woman from the rib which He had taken (note the past perfect translation of this Hebrew perfect in the RSV which Anderson has quoted) from man. That God did not intend one of the animals to be Adam's helper is evident from the singular versus plural contrast here and probably also from the different verbs that were juxtaposed in verses 18 and 19. The reference to the animals in verse 19 is parenthetical, therefore, and the conjunction with which this verse begins should be translated in a disjunctive manner to bring out this point. This fits the past perfect translation proposed for the verb which follows it. Thus the opening of Genesis 2:19 is best translated, "Now Yahweh God had formed every beast...." The preferable past perfect translation of this verb refers back to the creation of the beasts and birds on the 6th and 5th days of the preceding narrative respectively (note that both are mentioned here in an inverted order), and the verb at the beginning of Genesis 2:19 does not need to imply they were created again after man.
William H. Shea
Associate Professor of Old Testament
All contents copyright Geoscience Research Institute. All rights reserved.
Send comments and questions to firstname.lastname@example.org
| About Us | Contact Us |